It’s that time, people. The time when I look at how the postseason could be better and tackle the issues that plague FBS’s postseason at this point, which include:
- Potential high draft picks opting out of bowl games
- Some still thinking there are too many bowl games
- Major injuries that occur during these bowl games to players who would probably be in the draft
- Attendance problems at certain bowl games
- Going up against the NFL (and up here, the World Juniors)
Will my solution fix everything here? No. Especially the injury one. Those will happen. I can see potential first rounders still opting out in the future and that would be the main reason: preventing injury going into workouts and the Combine. The other three…yeah I can deal with those.
Look I have done this so many times before that I won’t link them here. You should be able to find them but if you do need help, let me know.
Now that we definitely have a 12-team playoff in a couple years, I have to adjust my solution a bit. I won’t go against what they are doing, I am just trying to enhance it for everyone’s enjoyment.
First thing we have to do is actually eliminate some of the bowl games. This will make the “Too Many Bowl Games” crowd happy but the reason I am doing this is to tighten things up a bit. ESPN Events owns about half of these anyway so I can’t see them being missed and I honestly doubt the economics of how much it helps a host city. So the following bowls will just have to cease to exist:
- Cure Bowl
- New Orleans Bowl
- Birmingham Bowl
- Quick Lane Bowl
- Frisco Bowl
- Arizona Bowl
- Cheez-It Bowl
- Bahamas Bowl
- LendingTree Bowl
For the most part, these bowl games will be missed by almost nobody. This allows for more bowl games to get their own national spotlights and makes it so we aren’t putting pretty much all 5-7 teams in to the postseason. I love college football but that, to me, is where it gets a bit absurd.
Now let’s get to the format, as it will be going forward (until people start griping and it expands to 16 teams). There is an advantage now for finishing at the top of the rankings AND for winning your conference championship. The first order of business is that divisions will be abolished in all FBS conferences. I don’t care if the Big Ten expands to the Big Ten Times Two (meaning twenty teams). No divisions. This way the best two teams get to the title game and we won’t see some weird 8-5 Wisconsin team somehow get a first-round bye. Also, at least one Group of Five team gets invited. More if they are in the Top 12 but we know it will be one for the foreseeable future. I know you’ve seen this a few times already on other websites or on ESPN but here’s what the top 12 will look like this with the new playoff criteria:
- Georgia (SEC champs)
- Michigan (Big Ten champs)
- Clemson (ACC champs)
- Utah (Pac-12 champs)
- TCU
- Ohio State
- Alabama
- Tennessee
- Kansas State
- USC
- Penn State
- Tulane
Sorry to Washington, Florida State, both Oregons and whoever else felt they should be in the field. You are denied this time. Do better.
Now to the format/schedule. Let’s use this year’s dates to show how this works to make it a tiny bit easier to understand. I’m also using the CFP’s newer date setup so it will be slightly different than mine was last year (and won’t interrupt the Army-Navy game). The other difference between this format and the one I used last year is that first round games will be on-campus. So those bowl games go back in the regular mix.
First Round Games – Friday, December 16th/Saturday December 17th (all times EST)
- Tulane at TCU (Friday, 8:00)
- Penn State at Ohio State (Saturday, Noon)
- USC at Alabama (Saturday, 3:30)
- Kansas State at Tennessee (Saturday, 7:00)
Really, you could mix and match as to where to put these games. The only thing that comes into play is when you have a team from the Mountain or Pacific time zones. You ideally should slot them either Friday or Saturday night and definitely not at Noon on the Saturday.
Quarter-Finals – Thursday, December 30th/Friday December 31st
Normally these games would be on December 31st, January 1st and January 2nd. This year that can’t be the case with New Year’s Day being a Sunday and you can’t have playoff games two days apart. The top-ranked team would be put at a bowl site that is most advantageous to them. Then the next team would be put in the best spot out of the bowls left and so forth until all four games are filled.
- Orange Bowl (Thursday, 8:00) – Georgia vs. Kansas State/Tennessee winner
- Sugar Bowl (Friday, Noon) – Clemson vs. Penn State/Ohio State winner
- Rose Bowl (Friday, 4:00) – Utah vs. Tulane/TCU winner
- Cotton Bowl (Friday, 8:00) – Michigan vs. USC/Alabama winner
Yes I have the Rose Bowl on New Year’s Eve. I think that’s a possibility going forward. I hope it is. Just to fuck with their commmittee.
Semi-Finals – Thursday, January 5th/Friday, January 6th
Can’t do Saturday and Sunday because it would interfere with the NFL (although I could see one game on an early Saturday).
- Peach Bowl (Thursday, 7:00) – Orange Bowl winner vs. Rose Bowl winner
- Fiesta Bowl (Friday, 8:00) – Cotton Bowl winner vs. Sugar Bowl winner
Again, The Committee would put Georgia in the best bowl for them which would obviously be the Peach Bowl. Even if they didn’t win, I think these semi-final combinations would be set in stone.
CFP National Championship – Monday, January 16th
So all this does is move the national championship one week back. Not a big deal really and still stays mostly out of the way of the NFL playoffs (which have also shifted back a week due to the extra regular season week they have now).
Only the six current New Year’s Six bowl games are being used as opposed to the ten I had in my scenario last year (I included the Gator, Citrus, Alamo and Holiday Bowls for the first round games).
Now for the rest of the bowl games. As you saw above, I lopped off nine of them. Would they even fill half the stadium? Maybe close but mostly likely not. I plan on not having any pre-Christmas daytime games. I say that every year. There are dumb. I get that not everyone works a 9ish-to-5ish job but, unfortunately to us night owls, the work world revolves around this schedule pretty closely. Even with PVRs still being a big thing, it’s pointless to have a bowl game on a random Wednesday before Christmas at 2 in the afternoon. Live sports are what most people want to see so having more games in primetime allows more people to watch. It’s actually pretty damn simple.
I also plan to move a few games off of ESPN. I hate the fact that games are pretty spread out among the networks all through the regular season. Then the bowl games come and WHAM! Pretty much all of them go to ESPN. Look, I will say I’m a bit selfish and patriotic because I am doing this, somewhat, for Canadians. Oh and with the Arizona Bowl being off the table, that means Barstool Sports is shit out of luck again. I assume one day they will pick up another bowl but for this scenario, nothing.
Bowl tie-ins are also going to be decreased as is what I do normally when I used to fix the bowl games. Many bowl games don’t even follow them anyway so why should I? I will have it set up like this:
- SEC, Big Ten, ACC – 5 bowl tie-ins
- Big XII, Pac-12 – 4 bowl tie-ins
- AAC, MWC, Sun Belt – 3 bowl tie-ins
- C-USA, MAC – 2 bowl tie-ins
If a team doesn’t get put in a bowl with a tie-in, they go to the at-large bucket. I believe this will make for at least a slightly better overall bowl lineup and my past posts have proven that. And I’m also going to have every Group of Five conference champion get to face a Power Five team in a bowl game. That’s a huge incentive compared to now where most of the G-5 conference champions get a banner and an unknown destination.
To qualify, teams must win seven games. If all those teams are placed and there are still more bowl slots, 6-win teams will be put in and let’s do it based on APR since that’s the way the NCAA does it with 5-win teams.
OK so now that that’s all out of the way, let’s get to what the tie-ins will look like:
January 4, 2023 | 10:30 PM | Las Vegas Bowl | Pac-12 | MWC |
January 4, 2023 | 7:00 PM | Gator Bowl | SEC | ACC |
January 3, 2023 | 10:30 PM | LA Bowl | Pac-12 | at-large |
January 3, 2023 | 7:00 PM | Duke’s Mayo Bowl | ACC | at-large |
January 2, 2023 | 3:00 PM | ReliaQuest Bowl | SEC | Big Ten |
January 2, 2023 | 12:00 PM | Citrus Bowl | SEC | Big Ten |
December 30, 2022 | 4:30 PM | Music City Bowl | SEC | Big Ten |
December 30, 2022 | 1:00 PM | Liberty Bowl | SEC | Sun Belt |
December 30, 2022 | Noon | Sun Bowl | Big XII | Pac-12 |
December 28, 2022 | 10:30 PM | Guaranteed Rate Bowl | at-large | at-large |
December 28, 2022 | 8:30 PM | Alamo Bowl | Big XII | at-large |
December 28, 2022 | 7:00 PM | Military Bowl | Big Ten | MAC |
December 28, 2022 | 3:30 PM | Gasparilla Bowl | ACC | AAC |
December 28, 2022 | Noon | Fenway Bowl | AAC | at-large |
December 27, 2022 | 8:30 PM | Texas Bowl | Big XII | at-large |
December 27, 2022 | 7:00 PM | Pinstripe Bowl | Big Ten | ACC |
December 27, 2022 | 5:00 PM | Camellia Bowl | Sun Belt | at-large |
December 27, 2022 | 1:30 PM | First Responder Bowl | Big XII | C-USA |
December 26, 2022 | 3:30 PM | Armed Forces Bowl | AAC | at-large |
December 26, 2022 | Noon | Boca Raton Bowl | ACC | at-large |
December 25, 2022 | Noon | Myrtle Beach Bowl | MAC | at-large |
December 24, 2022 | 9:30 PM | Hawaii Bowl | MWC | at-large |
December 23, 2022 | 8:00 PM | Holiday Bowl | Pac-12 | at-large |
December 22, 2022 | 9:30 PM | Idaho Potato Bowl | MWC | at-large |
December 21, 2022 | 9:30 PM | New Mexico Bowl | at-large | at-large |
December 20, 2022 | 8:00 PM | Independence Bowl | Sun Belt | C-USA |
As promised, all the Group of Five conference champions get their shot at a Power Five team in a bowl game. I still believe this is one of the things sorely missing from bowl season: the chance for a lower level team to go up against a potential power. Otherwise they are just playing an extra game. Good for the players and staff but in the end, it means jack shit because it won’t help nearly as much with recruiting and won’t enhance these schools brands when it comes to football.
There are also a lot of at-larges and we will get to that in a bit. Again, this is about trying my best to create a better bowl lineup and flexibility certainly helps in that regard.
And part of the way to do that is to overhaul the shitty Selection Sunday show that ESPN does. And it is shitty. Seriously shitty. You could take out 85% of the show and still get everything you need and more. To change this I will show you my perfect setup for the show, something I have done in previous years:
- Noon-12:05 – Introduction of hosts, panel and all the reporters at the various sites around the U.S. We don’t need Desmond Howard’s reasoning behind putting Texas A&M in the College Football Playoff at the start of the season and how it somehow ties into today’s proceedings. It doesn’t so knock it off.
- 12:05-1:00 – College Football Playoff rankings reveal and game selections. This includes analysis from everyone: Herbstreit, Desmond, Rece Davis, David Pollack, fifteen people from around the country. Then an interview with whomever heads The Committee and you’ve filled the rest of the first hour. Easy, right?
- 1:00-2:00 – Show the bowl tie-ins and do some analysis on those. I am giving a bit less time than I have in previous years to give as much time as possible to the at-large selection process which is the meat of the show (along with live look-ins to the players sitting around, awaiting their destination, a la the March Madness Selection Show.
- 2:00-3:45 – Selection time. The random order for selection would have been done the day prior so as to give bowl committees time to send out invites although in this day and age, it’s rare to see a team decline a bowl invite. At-large selections are shown as they are made. Analysis by the crew following every pick.
Yes it’s 4 hours long (last 15 minutes can be used to wrap everything up and remind people of when certain games air); but you can cram a lot of excitement and interest into those four hours rather than have people drone on and on about nothing.
So…here is what the bowl schedule would look like after slotting all the conferences’ tie-ins:
January 4, 2023 | 10:30 PM | ESPN | Las Vegas Bowl | Oregon | Fresno State |
January 4, 2023 | 7:00 PM | CBS | Gator Bowl | LSU | North Carolina |
January 3, 2023 | 10:30 PM | ESPN | LA Bowl | Washington | at-large |
January 3, 2023 | 7:00 PM | NBC | Duke’s Mayo Bowl | Florida State | at-large |
January 2, 2023 | 3:00 PM | ESPN | ReliaQuest Bowl | South Carolina | Purdue |
January 2, 2023 | 12:00 PM | ABC | Citrus Bowl | Kentucky | Iowa |
December 30, 2022 | 4:30 PM | ESPN | Music City Bowl | Mississippi State | Illinois |
December 30, 2022 | 1:00 PM | ESPN | Liberty Bowl | Ole Miss | Troy |
December 30, 2022 | Noon | CBS | Sun Bowl | Big XII | UCLA |
December 28, 2022 | 10:30 PM | ESPN | Guaranteed Rate Bowl | at-large | at-large |
December 28, 2022 | 8:30 PM | FOX | Alamo Bowl | Texas | at-large |
December 28, 2022 | 7:00 PM | ESPN | Military Bowl | Maryland | Toledo |
December 28, 2022 | 3:30 PM | ESPN | Gasparilla Bowl | Duke | UCF |
December 28, 2022 | Noon | ESPN | Fenway Bowl | Cincinnati | at-large |
December 27, 2022 | 8:30 PM | ESPN | Texas Bowl | Texas Tech | at-large |
December 27, 2022 | 7:00 PM | ABC | Pinstripe Bowl | Minnesota | Pittsburgh |
December 27, 2022 | 5:00 PM | ESPN | Camellia Bowl | South Alabama | at-large |
December 27, 2022 | 1:30 PM | ESPN | First Responder Bowl | Oklahoma State | UTSA |
December 26, 2022 | 3:30 PM | ESPN | Armed Forces Bowl | SMU | at-large |
December 26, 2022 | Noon | ESPN | Boca Raton Bowl | Syracuse | at-large |
December 25, 2022 | Noon | ESPN | Myrtle Beach Bowl | Ohio | at-large |
December 24, 2022 | 9:30 PM | ESPN | Hawaii Bowl | Wyoming | at-large |
December 23, 2022 | 8:00 PM | FOX | Holiday Bowl | Oregon State | at-large |
December 22, 2022 | 9:30 PM | ESPN | Idaho Potato Bowl | Boise State | at-large |
December 21, 2022 | 9:30 PM | ESPN | New Mexico Bowl | at-large | at-large |
December 20, 2022 | 8:00 PM | ESPN | Independence Bowl | James Madison | North Texas |
- The G-5 conference champion process has set up the following matchups:
- UCF (the runner-up in the American since Tulane is in the CFP) goes to the Gasparilla Bowl to play Duke.
- Fresno State (Mountain West champ) plays Oregon in the Las Vegas Bowl, which ends up being the final bowl game before the College Football Playoff semi-finals.
- The First Responder Bowl gets Conference USA champ UTSA and the high-octane offense of the Oklahoma State Cowboys.
- The Sun Belt champ (Troy) faces off against Ole Miss in the Liberty Bowl.
- Finally, the MAC champ, Toledo, plays Maryland in the Military Bowl. Yes the MAC will have to travel for every bowl game now that I have axed the Quick Lane Bowl.
- Some of the bowl matchups are the same (sorry, I still have Kentucky-Iowa) and some have probably improved a bit (Ole Miss-Troy looks like a good one).
- I have given FOX, ABC, CBS and even NBC some bowl games. ESPN will hate it but too fucking bad.
- Finally you will notice I have put James Madison in a bowl game. Yeah, fuck the transition rule. An 8-3 team should go to a bowl game. Period.
Alright so there are a bunch of teams left who have won at least seven games. Seventeen of them to be exact. For 17 spots. That worked out perfectly! You will notice that the Big XII did not have enough teams to fill the few bowl slots they had. So the Sun Bowl goes into the pool to pick from the remaining teams.
Here is that random draw and the teams I think would have been selected:
- LA – Notre Dame
- Armed Forces – BYU
- Boca Raton – Liberty
- Texas – Houston
- Camellia – Louisville
- Idaho Potato – Washington State
- Duke’s Mayo – East Carolina
- Myrtle Beach – Coastal Carolina
- Sun – Air Force
- Holiday – San Diego State
- New Mexico – San Jose State
- Alamo – Wake Forest
- Guaranteed Rate – NC State
- Hawaii – WKU
- Fenway – Eastern Michigan
- New Mexico – Marshall
- Guaranteed Rate – Middle Tennessee
So after these selections this is what the rest of the bowls (beyond the playoffs) would look like:
January 4, 2023 | 10:30 PM | ESPN | Las Vegas Bowl | Oregon | Fresno State |
January 4, 2023 | 7:00 PM | CBS | Gator Bowl | LSU | North Carolina |
January 3, 2023 | 10:30 PM | ESPN | LA Bowl | Washington | Notre Dame |
January 3, 2023 | 7:00 PM | NBC | Duke’s Mayo Bowl | Florida State | East Carolina |
January 2, 2023 | 3:00 PM | ESPN | ReliaQuest Bowl | South Carolina | Purdue |
January 2, 2023 | 12:00 PM | ABC | Citrus Bowl | Kentucky | Iowa |
December 30, 2022 | 4:30 PM | ESPN | Music City Bowl | Mississippi State | Illinois |
December 30, 2022 | 1:00 PM | ESPN | Liberty Bowl | Ole Miss | Troy |
December 30, 2022 | Noon | CBS | Sun Bowl | Air Force | UCLA |
December 28, 2022 | 10:30 PM | ESPN | Guaranteed Rate Bowl | NC State | Middle Tennessee |
December 28, 2022 | 8:30 PM | FOX | Alamo Bowl | Texas | Wake Forest |
December 28, 2022 | 7:00 PM | ESPN | Military Bowl | Maryland | Toledo |
December 28, 2022 | 3:30 PM | ESPN | Gasparilla Bowl | Duke | UCF |
December 28, 2022 | Noon | ESPN | Fenway Bowl | Cincinnati | Eastern Michigan |
December 27, 2022 | 8:30 PM | ESPN | Texas Bowl | Texas Tech | Houston |
December 27, 2022 | 7:00 PM | ABC | Pinstripe Bowl | Minnesota | Pittsburgh |
December 27, 2022 | 5:00 PM | ESPN | Camellia Bowl | South Alabama | Louisville |
December 27, 2022 | 1:30 PM | ESPN | First Responder Bowl | Oklahoma State | UTSA |
December 26, 2022 | 3:30 PM | ESPN | Armed Forces Bowl | SMU | BYU |
December 26, 2022 | Noon | ESPN | Boca Raton Bowl | Syracuse | Liberty |
December 25, 2022 | Noon | ESPN | Myrtle Beach Bowl | Ohio | Coastal Carolina |
December 24, 2022 | 9:30 PM | ESPN | Hawaii Bowl | Wyoming | WKU |
December 23, 2022 | 8:00 PM | FOX | Holiday Bowl | Oregon State | San Diego State |
December 22, 2022 | 9:30 PM | ESPN | Idaho Potato Bowl | Boise State | Washington State |
December 21, 2022 | 9:30 PM | ESPN | New Mexico Bowl | San Jose State | Marshall |
December 20, 2022 | 8:00 PM | ESPN | Independence Bowl | James Madison | North Texas |
So there are a few games that look quite a bit better than what we had. Especially when there are storylines like:
- Notre Dame facing Washington in what would be a massively hyped LA Bowl.
- The Texas Bowl gets a huge boost with two teams from the state playing.
- Syracuse/Liberty could end up being a juicy matchup.
- Coastal Carolina playing at home on Christmas Day.
- The Idaho Potato Bowl getting a massive boost with Wazzu coming in to face the hometown Broncos.
Is it a massive change? No, but when you do a few small things you can create a lot more excitement overall to a system that, outside the playoff, has become rather stagnant.
A reminder (you shouldn’t need it but here it is) that bowl season begins this morning! The Bahamas Bowl starts a three-week-plus college football postseason journey that ends with the national championship on January 9th. Along with the bowl games, there are playoff games in other divisions going on.
- FCS Semi-final: Incarnate Word at North Dakota State (Friday, 7:00, specialty pack)
- Division III Championship: North Central vs. Mount Union (in Annapolis) (Friday, 7:00, specialty pack)
- Division II Championship: Colorado School of Mines vs. Ferris State (in McKinney, Texas) (Saturday, 1:00, specialty pack)
- FCS Semi-final: Montana State at South Dakota State (Saturday, 4:00, specialty pack)
From what I can see, the specialty packs are being dickheads again with none of these games listed. I hope they show up but I know last weekend I only remembered them appearing on Bell guides. Fingers crossed. Especially with the FCS games as it feels like we are heading for a Battle of the Dakotas for the FCS National Championship.
Alright, enjoy the games everyone. A LOT of football between now and Sunday night. Savour it.