I’ve tried to remake the bowl system. I’ve gone farther and tried my hand at fixing the postseason in college football. Now let’s go back to the sport’s roots (kind of) and do a Poll n’ Bowl version! What’s Poll n’ Bowl? Well it was the way things were before the BCS. Let’s even go before conference championships. The final regular season poll was followed by bowl games. That’s it, that’s all. And then the national championship was selected after the bowls were done. Easy peasy.
Now it’s time to do a little math. I decided to just pick a season at random and determine the amount of bowl games and Division 1-A (not FBS yet) teams. There were 110 teams and 18 bowl games in the 1985 season. That meant that approximately 1/3rd of teams would get into a bowl game. Not even close to the percentage this season which was over 60%. So bowls were much more important back then because they were a bit more prestigious. Couldn’t go 6-5 a lot of times (only a 11-game regular season back then) and make it into a bowl game. With 130 teams, that would mean about 44 teams should qualify meaning there should be 22 bowl games if we are treating this like we would have in the 80s.
So I have to come up with some criteria here because a .500 record isn’t enough to get to a bowl game. So I have decided to make it so a team would need 8 wins to be bowl-eligible. This will make it a bit more difficult for Group of Five teams to qualify but that’s the way it was in the Poll n’ Bowl era. Saying that, it also meant that a team from a non-power conference that made a bowl game was actually really good.
Also I need to go back and find some historic bowl games from the past. No more Bahamas Bowl. Say good bye Frisco Football Classic. Playing in the LA Bowl? Not anymore. To get back to the roots (so to speak) we need to use the same vernacular as you saw back in the 80s and 90s when it came to bowl season.
Hey, remember when all the bowl games weren’t on ESPN? Well it’s time to, kind of, go back to that. Give the other networks a game or two and spread the wealth so to speak. And put the fucking Rose Bowl back on ABC…and the Sugar Bowl while you’re at it!
I’m going to have to take a few liberties with the bowl tie-ins. Older bowl games won’t obviously have the same tie-ins as they do now. Hell, the American Conference didn’t exist until about a decade ago. Don’t worry, some matchups will still exist. The Big Ten and Pac-12 champions will face off in the Granddaddy of them All, the Rose Bowl. That will not change. But a lot of the rest will, I’m not going to lie.
So here is what the structure would look like. Obviously there could be some tweaks but I want to have national spotlights for every bowl game:
January 10, 2022 |
8:00 |
National Championship |
ESPN |
#1 |
#2 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
January 1, 2022 |
8:45 |
USF&G Sugar Bowl |
ABC |
SEC Champ |
at-large |
|
|
January 1, 2022 |
5:00 |
Rose Bowl presented by AT&T |
ABC |
Big Ten Champ |
Pac-12 Champ |
|
|
January 1, 2022 |
1:00 |
Tostitos Fiesta Bowl |
NBC |
Big Ten |
Big XII |
|
|
December 31, 2021 |
7:30 |
FedEx Orange Bowl |
NBC |
ACC Champ |
at-large |
|
|
December 31, 2021 |
3:30 |
Mobil Cotton Bowl |
ESPN |
Big XII Champ |
SEC |
|
|
December 31, 2021 |
Noon |
Chick-fil-A Peach Bowl |
ESPN |
at-large |
at-large |
|
|
December 30, 2021 |
9:00 |
Bluebonnet Bowl |
FOX |
Big XII |
at-large |
|
|
December 30, 2021 |
5:30 |
Buffalo Wild Wings Citrus Bowl |
ESPN |
SEC |
ACC |
|
|
December 30, 2021 |
2:00 |
Hall of Fame Bowl |
ESPN |
Big Ten |
ACC |
|
|
December 29, 2021 |
7:00 |
Mazda Gator Bowl |
CBS |
American Champ |
at-large |
|
|
December 29, 2021 |
3:00 |
John Hancock Sun Bowl |
CBS |
Pac-12 |
at-large |
|
|
December 28, 2021 |
8:00 |
St. Jude Liberty Bowl |
ESPN |
at-large |
at-large |
|
|
December 25, 2021 |
3:30 |
Roady’s Humanitarian Bowl |
ESPN |
MWC Champ |
at-large |
|
|
December 24, 2021 |
8:00 |
All-American Bowl |
ESPN |
C-USA Champ |
at-large |
|
|
December 24, 2021 |
4:30 |
Poulan Weed Eater Independence Bowl |
ESPN |
Sun Belt Champ |
at-large |
|
|
December 22, 2021 |
8:00 |
Pacific Life Holiday Bowl |
FOX |
Pac-12 |
at-large |
|
|
December 21, 2021 |
10:30 |
EA Sports Las Vegas Bowl |
ESPN |
MWC |
at-large |
|
|
December 21, 2021 |
7:00 |
GoDaddy.com Bowl |
ESPN |
at-large |
at-large |
|
|
December 18, 2021 |
9:30 |
Alamo Bowl presented by MasterCard |
ESPN |
at-large |
at-large |
|
|
December 18, 2021 |
6:00 |
Little Caesar’s Bowl |
ESPN |
MAC Champ |
at-large |
|
|
December 18, 2021 |
2:30 |
Blockbuster Bowl |
ABC |
American |
at-large |
|
|
December 18, 2021 |
11:00 |
Gaylord Hotels Music City Bowl |
ABC |
at-large |
at-large |
|
|
Alright this will look quite a bit different than the normal bowl schedule you see these days. Let’s get into the details:
- There are a lot of at-large bids, more than you would normally see. Remember, there were always quite a few Independent teams back in the 80s so you can’t tie all the bowls into a conference.
- I can’t do what I do with my postseason fixes and that’s make sure the Group of Five conference champions get to face a Power Five team in a bowl game. That’s just not possible. Not saying it won’t happen but it’s not guaranteed.
- There’s one thing I would do differently than used to be done. I would pit the top two teams against each other AFTER all the bowls are completed. That would be the true national championship. The site can be rotated and does not have to be a bowl game site. Like this year in Indianapolis.
- ESPN isn’t broadcasting 90% of the bowl games here. I have definitely spread the wealth including what I said earlier in the post: putting the Rose and Sugar Bowls back on ABC.
- I even put in some of the old sponsors. Some of these businesses don’t even exist anymore! But man, to hear Brent Musburger say, one more time, “This one is for all the Tostitos” would be great.
Alright this is where it gets a little weird. Because we only have a few Independent Teams now and some of them are horrible (UMass, UConn), many teams from conferences will have to fill the at-large spots. This is fine. What isn’t fine is getting all the tie-ins completed and then doing the at-large bids. It would mean that the way I have set things, the Sugar Bowl would always get one team that isn’t exactly New Year’s Day worthy if you know what I mean. To get around this, we will just start from the top and work our way down. If a bowl committee has an at-large bid and wants a team that’s not an Independent, they can just invite them. The only thing that’s set here, really, is the conference champion slots. Those cannot be changed. Clear as mud, right? Alright, let’s just fill these in the way I have a feeling they would have been filled in (given the rankings this year):
January 10, 2022 |
8:00 |
National Championship |
ESPN |
#1 |
#2 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
January 1, 2022 |
8:45 |
USF&G Sugar Bowl |
ABC |
SEC Champ |
at-large |
#1 Alabama |
#5 Notre Dame |
January 1, 2022 |
5:00 |
Rose Bowl presented by AT&T |
ABC |
Big Ten Champ |
Pac-12 Champ |
#2 Michigan |
#11 Utah |
January 1, 2022 |
1:00 |
Tostitos Fiesta Bowl |
NBC |
Big Ten |
Big XII |
#6 Ohio State |
#9 Oklahoma State |
December 31, 2021 |
7:30 |
FedEx Orange Bowl |
NBC |
ACC Champ |
at-large |
#12 Pittsburgh |
#3 Georgia |
December 31, 2021 |
3:30 |
Mobil Cotton Bowl |
ESPN |
Big XII Champ |
SEC |
#7 Baylor |
#8 Ole Miss |
December 31, 2021 |
Noon |
Chick-fil-A Peach Bowl |
ESPN |
at-large |
at-large |
#10 Michigan State |
#17 Wake Forest |
December 30, 2021 |
9:00 |
Bluebonnet Bowl |
FOX |
Big XII |
at-large |
#16 Oklahoma |
#13 BYU |
December 30, 2021 |
5:30 |
Buffalo Wild Wings Citrus Bowl |
ESPN |
SEC |
ACC |
#21 Arkansas |
#18 NC State |
December 30, 2021 |
2:00 |
Hall of Fame Bowl |
ESPN |
Big Ten |
ACC |
#15 Iowa |
#19 Clemson |
December 29, 2021 |
7:00 |
Mazda Gator Bowl |
CBS |
American Champ |
at-large |
#4 Cincinnati |
#22 Kentucky |
December 29, 2021 |
3:00 |
John Hancock Sun Bowl |
CBS |
Pac-12 |
at-large |
#14 Oregon |
#24 San Diego State |
December 28, 2021 |
8:00 |
St. Jude Liberty Bowl |
ESPN |
at-large |
at-large |
#20 Houston |
#25 Texas A&M |
December 25, 2021 |
3:30 |
Roady’s Humanitarian Bowl |
ESPN |
MWC Champ |
at-large |
Utah State |
Central Michigan |
December 24, 2021 |
8:00 |
All-American Bowl |
ESPN |
C-USA Champ |
at-large |
UTSA |
Minnesota |
December 24, 2021 |
4:30 |
Poulan Weed Eater Independence Bowl |
ESPN |
Sun Belt Champ |
at-large |
#23 Louisiana |
Wisconsin |
December 22, 2021 |
8:00 |
Pacific Life Holiday Bowl |
FOX |
Pac-12 |
at-large |
Arizona State |
Fresno State |
December 21, 2021 |
10:30 |
EA Sports Las Vegas Bowl |
ESPN |
MWC |
at-large |
Air Force |
UCLA |
December 21, 2021 |
7:00 |
GoDaddy.com Bowl |
ESPN |
at-large |
at-large |
Western Kentucky |
Nevada |
December 18, 2021 |
9:30 |
Alamo Bowl presented by MasterCard |
ESPN |
at-large |
at-large |
UAB |
SMU |
December 18, 2021 |
6:00 |
Little Caesar’s Bowl |
ESPN |
MAC Champ |
at-large |
Northern Illinois |
Purdue |
December 18, 2021 |
2:30 |
Blockbuster Bowl |
ABC |
American |
at-large |
UCF |
Appalachian State |
December 18, 2021 |
11:00 |
Gaylord Hotels Music City Bowl |
ABC |
at-large |
at-large |
Coastal Carolina |
Army |
So how does the national championship game get filed? Here are the scenarios:
- Alabama is in if they win the Sugar Bowl.
- Michigan is in if they win the Rose Bowl or if Georgia or Alabama lose.
- Georgia is in if they win by a good margin and Michigan does not (or outright loses) or if Alabama loses.
- Cincinnati is in if they blow the bricks off of Kentucky and if Michigan, Georgia, and Ohio State all lose.
- Notre Dame is in if they beat Alabama and if one of Michigan or Georgia loses.
Other than complete chaos, there are no other scenarios for the national championship game in my opinion.
Alright is that better? I honestly don’t know. The Cotton Bowl is the same matchup as what we got but some of the other bowl games are wildly different. I think the addition of the Plus-One is what was always missing from that era and they let it go by the wayside with the introduction of the Bowl Alliance and then the BCS. Now you can’t put the toothpaste back in the tube and we are headed for an expanded playoff. Will this kill off the bowl games? Not unless they don’t bring in the viewers which they still do at this point…to the tune of millions per game in some cases. Doesn’t mean the system will be good, it just is what it will end up being.
Just a note: the FCS National Championship is Saturday. You can see it on TSN2 before the Saturday NFL games start. And then the College Football Playoff is Monday night. It’s on every TSN channel except TSN5. As far as I can tell, the normal broadcast will be on TSN1 and TSN4 and the Megacast broadcast will be on TSN2 and TSN3. And then that will be it for college football for the season (except for the weird all-star games). So cherish it. Have a great rest of the week!